Compare cities · September 2026
Mahtomedi vs. New Brighton
Homes in Mahtomedi sold for a median $475,000 over the 12 months through September 2026, 22% more than in New Brighton ($390,250). Homes sold faster in Mahtomedi: 37 days on market on average, against 42 in New Brighton. Mahtomedi's homes are newer, with a median year built of 1989 against 1973. New Brighton is closer to downtown Minneapolis: about 18 minutes by car, against 32. The two are about 12 miles apart.
Housing market, 12 months through September 2026
| Measure | Mahtomedi | New Brighton |
|---|---|---|
| Median sale price | $475,000 | $390,250 |
| Change from a year earlier | +2.2% | +1.9% |
| Homes sold | 123 | 254 |
| Days on market | 37 | 42 |
| Share of original list price | 98.9% | 99.0% |
| Price per square foot | $237 | $199 |
| New listings | 154 | 331 |
| Homes for sale (September 2026) | 18 | 57 |
| Months of supply (September 2026) | 1.7 | 2.7 |
Source: Minneapolis Area REALTORS® Local Market Update (NorthstarMLS data).
The homes
| Measure | Mahtomedi | New Brighton |
|---|---|---|
| Median home value (owner estimate) | $476,000 | $364,700 |
| Median year built | 1989 | 1973 |
| Single-family homesShare of all housing units, detached houses | 83% | 58% |
| Owner-occupied homes | 83% | 61% |
| Median rent | $1,694 | $1,397 |
Source: US Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020–2024.
The place
| Measure | Mahtomedi | New Brighton |
|---|---|---|
| Population (2024) | 8,199 | 22,374 |
| Land area | 3.5 sq mi | 6.5 sq mi |
| Drive to Downtown Minneapolis | 32 min | 18 min |
| Drive to Downtown Saint Paul | 24 min | 19 min |
| Drive to MSP Airport | 35 min | 30 min |
| Drive to Mall of America | 39 min | 31 min |
| Drive to University of Minnesota | 30 min | 16 min |
| Average commute to work | 23.6 min | 20 min |
| Lakes of 10+ acresMinnesota DNR lake outlines touching the city | 4 | 4 |
Source: US Census Bureau 2024 estimates and TIGER/Line; drive times from OpenStreetMap routing (light traffic).
Mahtomedi
School districts: Mahtomedi Public School District
Largest lakes: White Bear Lake (2,428 acres), Long Lake (63 acres), Long Lake (53 acres), Lost Lake (22 acres)
New Brighton
School districts: Mounds View Public School District, St. Anthony-New Brighton Schools
Largest lakes: Long Lake (173 acres), Silver Lake (71 acres), Rush Lake (45 acres), Pike Lake (38 acres)
How we compare places: by their homes, housing market and location only, from public sources, never by who lives there. Medians describe the middle home; both places have homes well above and below them.
Quick answers
Mahtomedi or New Brighton?
Is Mahtomedi or New Brighton more expensive?
Mahtomedi. The median sale price was $475,000 there and $390,250 in New Brighton over the 12 months through September 2026, according to the Minneapolis Area REALTORS® Local Market Update. The median is the middle sale, so both have homes well above and below it.
Where do homes sell faster, Mahtomedi or New Brighton?
Mahtomedi: 37 days on market on average against 42, over the 12 months through September 2026.
Which is closer to downtown Minneapolis?
New Brighton, about 18 minutes by car in light traffic (32 from Mahtomedi). To downtown Saint Paul: 24 minutes from Mahtomedi, 19 from New Brighton.
How far apart are Mahtomedi and New Brighton?
About 12 miles in a straight line between their centers.
Which has more lakes, Mahtomedi or New Brighton?
They have the same number: 4 lakes of 10+ acres touch Mahtomedi (largest: White Bear Lake) and 4 touch New Brighton (largest: Long Lake), by Minnesota DNR lake outlines.
Which school districts serve Mahtomedi and New Brighton?
Mahtomedi: Mahtomedi Public School District. New Brighton: Mounds View Public School District and St. Anthony-New Brighton Schools. School district lines don't follow city lines, so check the district for a specific address before you buy.
Should I buy in Mahtomedi or New Brighton?
It depends on your budget, the kind of home you want and where you need to get to each day. This page compares the homes, prices and locations; a Huerkamp Home Group agent can show you homes in both and walk you through what's selling now.
Keep comparing
More comparisons
Deciding between them?
See homes in Mahtomedi and New Brighton.
A Huerkamp Home Group agent can show you homes in both, tell you what's selling and for how much right now, and help you decide. There's no cost to buyers.